Thursday, March 21, 2019

Readmissions and Mortality–Any Difference by Race?

Since the introduction of Hospital Readmission Reduction Program by the CMS, there has been a significant decrease in readmissions for all targetted diseases. However, studies have raised concern that although readmissions are decreasing, there may be an increase in mortality.

A recent study showed that there is no difference in mortality between white and black patients. Authors used interrupted time-series analysis. I enjoyed statistical modelling but wonder if the within-hospital and between hosptial effects were properly accounted for. In other words, the assumption in their modeling is that both effects are the same (unlikely to be true). It is possible that the within and between effects are different and may shed a better light on what is happening at individual hospital level and what is happening across hospitals. Having said that, it is an interesting study with important implications.

Friday, March 15, 2019

Are Machine Learning Tools Better than Standard Tools in Predicting Readmissions

Just saw this study where authors compared standard readmission tools (HOSPITAL score, modified LACE score, and Maxim/RightCare score) with a model developed using machine learning. Authors found that machine learning score (they called it Baltimore Score or B-score) performed much better than standard tools.

While I agree that machine learning tools will likely outperform standard methods. Standard methods are quite a bit of oversimplification of the real life, machine learning tools less so. However, I doubt that authors have got their model right. Two reasons: One, their sample size is relatively small. Two, they have not validated their tool in a new dataset.

Thursday, March 14, 2019

Social risk factors adjustment for readmission penalties

I have shown, in my previous work, that social risk factors affect hospital performance. CMS, at th eurging of Congress, will be including including social risk factors in their patient risk models. Here is an interesting paper that examined retrospectively the effect of adjustment for social risk factors on readmission penalties and found that the penalties will drop by almost half for safety-net hospitals. I am certain that these adjustment will bring more fairness in hospital comparisons and will decrease the amount of penalty these safety-net hospitals have to face.