WOEST - Optimal Antiplatelet Treatment in Patient Already taking Anticoagulants

Dual antiplatelet therapy (aspirin and clopidogrel or another P2Y12 inhibitor) is almost always prescribed (and is beneficial in preventing future adverse cardiovascular events) to patients with coronary artery disease who undergo coronary intervention and have stents placed (although it is associated with increased risk of bleeding). For most patients with atrial fibrillation or mechanical heart valves, anticoagulation therapy is a the standard of care (although it is associated with increased bleeding risk).

Question remains as to what to do with patients who are on anticoagulation but then develop coronary artery disease, undergo percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) and stent placement. Use of dual antiplatelet therapy along with anticoagulation increases the overall risk of bleeding considerably and whether such a high risk of bleeding overshadows the benefit associated with dual antiplatelet therapy remains unknown.

In an ideal situation, one would randomize patients who are taking anticoagulants and who have undergone PCI with stent placement in one of the three arms: dual antiplatelet therapy, aspirin alone, or clopidogrel (or another P2Y12 agent) alone. Of course, all the three groups should continue taking their anticoagulation treatment. While, we don’t have such an ideal study, we do have results of a study (reported today in the ESC Congress 2012) in which patients taking anticoagulants were randomized to dual antiplatelet agents or clopidogrel alone. The results are interesting; not only that dual antiplatelet therapy in addition to anticoagulation was associated with increased risk of bleeding, it was also associated with higher risk of all-cause mortality (6.4% vs. 2.5%; p = 0.027).

One thing is certain from this study and that is that dual antiplatelet therapy, in addition to anticoagulation, is not optimal treatment and a single antiplatelet agent is likely to do a better job in reducing not only bleeding but also in decreasing all-cause mortality. However, whether this single antiplatelet agent has to be aspirin or clopidogrel, that remains unclear. In fact, it is quite possible that aspirin may have larger benefit than clopidogrel when used in such population. Perhaps future studies may be better able to point us relative benefits of antiplatelet agents in patients with PCI and stents who are also taking anticoagulants.